jackiedoherty.org

News, schools, and views from a uniquely Lowell perspective
25th May 2008

What’s wrong with this picture?

posted in In the News, National issues |

Yesterday’s Globe reported that “nearly 300 people were sentenced this week to five months in prison for working at a meatpacking plant with false documents.” The immigrants, who are here illegally from Guatemala, were arrested at the Iowa plant on May 12 and taken to the grounds of the National Cattle Congress. In a span of four days, 297 people were convinced to plead guilty to avoid higher penalties and sentenced to five months in jail—how’s that for due process? They will be deported immediately after completing their jail terms. Later in the article, it states, “No charges have been brought against managers or owners…” This whole episode makes me sick to my stomach. If this crime of working to pack animal carcasses without proper papers is so atrocious, why aren’t the owners being sent to prison for hiring them? And what will happen to the company? Will it shut down or just ship in a new group of presumably low-paid workers to exploit? But the real kicker is, if they’re being deported anyway, why make them sit in prison for five months first? So they can be fed and housed on the taxpayers’ dime? The whole thing makes no sense (a combination of mean and stupid). It stinks, I imagine, as bad as a meatpacking plant…

There are currently 5 responses to “What’s wrong with this picture?”

Why not let us know what you think by adding your own comment! Your opinion is as valid as anyone elses, so come on... let us know what you think.

  1. 1 On May 26th, 2008, kpem said:

    “Court records indicate that after the workers voted in 2005 to join the United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Agriprocessors put the Social Security numbers of all voting employees into a federal database and discovered that most of the Social Security numbers were either nonexistent or belonged to other people.

    The company then fired the workers and sought to invalidate their vote to join the union. An administrative law judge rejected the company’s arguments.

    The National Labor Relations Board ordered the company to bargain with the union.”

    This company has taken advantage of their employees over and over again. In order to stop the employees from unionizing they “suddenly” realized that they had illegals working there and that should make the union vote not count. Then they fired them all. Now they rehired them all? These immigrants should be deported now with no jail time and the owners and managers of this company should go to jail for a long time. Their lie that they did not know about these employees status in 2005 to evade unionizing must also break some labor laws?

  2. 2 On May 27th, 2008, kpem said:

    This company is as bad as it gets and people should be outraged if charges are not filed. In 1995 they ran the social security numbers of all their employeees(like they could not have done that prior to hiring them) and then used the information that most of them were illegal to try to void the vote to unionize. They then fired all the illegals. They must not have been too serious about getting rid of the illegal workers because they went and rehired all illegals again. They ran the social security numbers in the past to use it against the union so they can not argue ignorance.

  3. 3 On May 28th, 2008, Jackie said:

    Wow! Thanks for the additional information. I agree with you that in fairness the owners should be held responsible, but that doesn’t address the harsh punishment imposed on the workers, not to mention their family members. Nor is it a remedy for the issue overall.

  4. 4 On May 29th, 2008, kpems said:

    When I read how they were walked in with shackles to a makeshift “tent” court area I immediately thought of the Salem Witch Trials. I feel that we should make it much easier for these people to become American citizens and that there should be a “legal” way for these people to stay here in the future. (as long as they have no criminal records) At the present time, with the present laws, we have no choice but to deport these people and we need to make sure that no families are split up.

  5. 5 On May 30th, 2008, Jackie said:

    Just like we used to have segregation laws, and laws that women couldn’t own property or vote, these laws and the entire immigration system needs complete reform. Ripping families apart and inprisoning these people is more than unjust, it’s inhumane.

  • Blogroll

  • Contact Us

  • Education Links

  • Local Groups

  • Local media